Fleischmann statement on Headrick campaign news

U.S. Rep. Chuck Fleischmann provided a brief statement upon hearing that his Democratic opponent, Dr. Mary Headrick, has had to put campaigning on hold for a few days to attend to a critically ill family member.

“I was saddened by the news of Dr. Headrick’s brother. My family and I will keep her and her family in our prayers,” Fleischmann said.

Headrick campaign paused due to family illness

Dr. Mary Headrick is suspending her campaigning activities for the U.S. House 3rd District race “for a few days,” due to her brother’s critical illness and emergency surgery, campaign spokeswoman Pat Combs said in a release.

“Dr. Headrick asked that people pray for her brother, Greer, to have a successful operation and recovery,” the statement said.

More information will be posted as it becomes available.

Democrats unite behind Paul Smith at fundraiser

Even though some of the local Democratic Party faithful expressed their displeasure with Chairman Paul Smith by refusing to attend, the Choo Choo Imperial Ballroom was fairly filled with cheering supporters on Wednesday at the party’s annual Kefauver Dinner. Organizers said the event was sold-out.

Smith and his longtime friend, former Senate Majority Leader Ward Crutchfield, each received several ovations from the crowd at the urging of speakers ranging from Sen. Beverly Marrero of Memphis to Crutchfield’s daughter Missy, who heads the Chattanooga Department of Education, Arts & Culture, and who emceed the event.

The majority of those in attendance seemed willing to forgive and forget the elder Crutchfield’s 2005 arrest and 2007 conviction on federal bribery charges, though some were seen keeping their seats while the rest stood.

A few party stalwarts privately hinted that Smith may face a leadership challenge at the next re-organization meeting (to take place in Spring 2013), even as they asserted that the current rift is more personal than political. One member expressed a desire to see younger people move into party leadership, but said that the fundraiser is a time to emphasize party unity, adding that the re-organization will be the time to “air the dirty laundry.”

Missy Crutchfield used some of her time at the lectern to rather openly lobby mayoral candidate Sen. Andy Berke to continue the department she administers, which was created in 2005 by current Mayor Ron Littlefield, should he win the March 2013 election. (She also alluded to a common perception that Berke is a shoo-in by referring to the election as a “coronation.”)

D. Bruce Shine, a Kingsport attorney and former staffer for Estes Kefauver, gave a biographical sketch of the Tennessee Congressman, U.S. Senator, and vice presidential candidate. Other speakers included Rev. Kenneth Love, Rep. JoAnne Favors, Sen. Beverly Marrero, and U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen. Collectively they extolled the virtues of organized labor and excoriated Republican-led legislative changes such as the requirement for voters to show photo identification at the polling place.

Candidates in the November election were recognized on the podium: Favors, Frank Eaton, Dr. Mary Headrick, Jim Lewis, Andraé McGary, and Sandy Norris Smith all were declared “winners” by Love. Following their recognition, candidates in the 2013 municipal election were invited to stand.

The annual Kefauver award, chosen by the party chair, was presented to Sandy Lusk, Missy Crutchfield, Jane Bowen-Forsythe, and Roger Graham.

Full disclosure: I was not able to stay through the entire event, and therefore missed the keynote speech by U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen (D-Memphis). Times Free Press reporter Shelly Bradbury covered it through its conclusion.

What is ‘nonpartisan’? A view behind the scenes of the Brainerd forum

Tuesday evening’s candidate meet-and-greet and forum was sponsored by the Brainerd Unity Group, which bills itself as a nonpartisan community organization. I am a member of the group, though I confess I’m not regularly active in it, and I’ve slacked a couple of years on dues. (I’m paid-up now.)

When Candy Corneliussen, one of the group’s steering committee members, introduced me as the moderator, she described Tennessee Ticket as a “nonpartisan…or bipartisan” blog.

Media reports both before and after the forum made much of the fact that not many Republican candidates accepted the invitation to attend. The Democrats in attendance also attempted to heap shame on their GOP counterparts for being no-shows.

There are several factors that help round out the story. I want to make sure readers know as much as possible.

  • Todd Gardenhire, candidate for the Senate District 10 seat, was already booked for an event in Bradley County when I contacted the campaign to invite him.
  • That said, Marti Rutherford is Gardenhire’s scheduling person. There is enmity between Rutherford and the Brainerd Unity Group (or certain of its leaders) that dates back to the time Rutherford resigned from the Chattanooga City Council. I asked if a surrogate could attend in Gardenhire’s stead, and Rutherford rightly expressed concern about having someone speak on the candidate’s behalf. I suggested maybe just sending someone to hand out fliers and bumper stickers who wouldn’t participate in the forum.
  • Rep. Gerald McCormick is virtually unopposed in House District 26. (Rodger Cooksey is an independent on the ballot, but I cannot locate any information about his campaign.) The 26th does not really involve the Brainerd area.
  • Mike Carter is the only candidate running in District 29. The 29th does include a Brainerd precinct or two, but for the most part is drawn around the fast-growing Ooltewah area.
  • Rep. Richard Floyd probably feels fairly safe in his reelection effort, which is why he probably didn’t choose to face his District 27 opponent, Frank Eaton.
  • Rep. Vince Dean probably feels fairly safe in his reelection effort, which is why he probably didn’t choose to face his District 30 opponent, Sandy Norris Smith.
  • Since many (though not all) of the Brainerd Unity Group’s leaders are Democrats, it was my responsibility (as an Independent) to contact the Republican candidates. It is possible that I was not diligent or persuasive enough, even though I made every effort, given my schedule, to ensure all candidates knew they were invited to participate, including U.S. Rep. Chuck Fleischmann.

A few Republicans were at the event (including Oscar Brock, who manned a Romney/Ryan table), but they were greatly outnumbered. This is consistent with what I have observed about many political events in this town, whether explicitly partisan or not—and no matter which explicit or implicit party puts on the show. They are generally lopsided.

And I just wonder if that is all right and good. If we try too hard to sterilize these things, they may just become yawnfests that nobody wants to attend. One of my Republican friends who attended Tuesday acknowledged his ideological minority status, but quickly added that he has fairly “thick skin,” so it didn’t matter. He got to see how the other side thought. I think that’s great, but I don’t expect everyone to act similarly.

Even so, I do wish more GOP candidates had come to the Brainerd forum. As the moderator, my aim was to give voters of all stripes a fair view into the mindsets of candidates of all stripes. And if I were a campaign consultant (which I don’t ever want to be, for the record), I would highly encourage my candidate to make every possible effort to be in front of potential voters, no matter how seemingly “hostile” the political territory. In-person appearances do matter.

For the record, I do not consider Tennessee Ticket to be “bipartisan.” I spend too much time trying to inform citizens that there are often more than the two media-supplied choices for that to be accurate. I am not sure if “nonpartisan” or “unpartisan” is the correct descriptor, but you get the idea. At the same time, I am realistic about the fact that, most often, an election will produce either a Democratic or Republican winner. I try to be fair to that reality as well as to all potential alternatives.

We all have choices to make—even the candidates, on where they will show up. But if any candidate felt like he was not suitably welcomed to the October 2nd event, allow me to extend an apology (though I have no evidence to suggest that is the case).

Aside from all this: please review your choices in the upcoming election as they relate to your personal values, and please vote accordingly.

TN-03 candidates on health care: repeal, replace, reform, or reinvigorate

(If the Storify article does not appear below, you may click here to read it.)


TN-03 candidates on health care: repeal, replace, reform, or reinvigorate

Third District candidates offer their ideas on what Congress should do about health care in America

Storified by TennesseeTicket · Tue, Jul 10 2012 05:00:09

Monday evening, the Probasco auditorium inside Erlanger Health System’s Baroness campus was nearly filled with medical professionals who had come to hear U.S. Rep. Chuck Fleischmann and five of his challengers—Democrats Dr. Mary Headrick and Bill Taylor, and Republicans Ron Bhalla, Scottie Mayfield, and Weston Wamp—answer questions about the current and future state of health care. The Chattanooga Times Free Press co-sponsored and moderated the forum. Here’s their coverage:
New health care law has little support at 3rd District candidate forum in Chattanooga (with video)Candidates address health care In surprising bits of bipartisan agreement, U.S. Rep. Chuck Fleischmann, R-Tenn., and five challengers sai…
Following is a selection of Twitter updates by Nooga.com’s James Harrison and myself during the event.
Here’s a pic of @MayfieldScottie making his opening remarks with @RepChuck, @westonwamp and @BillTaylor3rd looking on: http://t.co/CZnPzfU3James Harrison
Mayfield says he will work to "keep patient & doctor relationship where it ought to be" if elected in #TN03.TennesseeTicket
Responding to question on how TennCare may have prepped TN for new law, Mayfield talks about how he thinks ACA will hurt small businesses.James Harrison
Democrat Bill Taylor says he’s for leaving the health care law in place, and modifying it over time to make it better.James Harrison
On ACA ruling: Wamp says 1st step is repeal; then give tax credits to spend as needed on healthcare; promotes exchangesTennesseeTicket
Before offering solution, @RepChuck says he’s already voted to repeal Obamacare, and will do so again this week.James Harrison
Bill Taylor says some parts of ACA need repeal, others improved; hits large medical insurersTennesseeTicket
Bhalla: ACA will hurt small businesses; need ins cos to reduce premium and deductiblesTennesseeTicket
Headrick: been fighting for healthcare reform, the ACA is not her favorite, but would not vote to repeal. Need wider focus than insurance.TennesseeTicket
Fleischmann: I have and will vote to repeal. Looking for tort reform as part of free market healthcare reformsTennesseeTicket
Flessner: should TN expand Medicaid, proceed with healthcare exchange? Taylor: yes, but ins cos will not participate if rate not desirableTennesseeTicket
Mayfield: yes exchanges, to preempt fedgov action (if ACA not repealed)TennesseeTicket
Mayfield says he has faith in #TNLeg to oversee health care exchanges resulting from ACA because of their recent work on tort reform.James Harrison
Headrick: "Let’s not spend money on health insurance, let’s spend on healthcare." wants public option among exchange choices; single payerTennesseeTicket
On TennCare: Mayfield says 1st 10 yrs was harbinger of what will happen under ACA. Not affordable.TennesseeTicket
Headrick: TennCare was implemented without "sound actuarial principles" but has helped move state fwd after fixesTennesseeTicket
Fleischmann says tort reform has helped stem costs of TennCare; says state should go further, enact "loser pays"TennesseeTicket
Fleischmann and Mayfield say they’d both be for tort reform on the federal level. Wamp "likes the idea" of it being a state by state issue.James Harrison
None of the candidates raised a hand when asked if healthcare is a right. Only Taylor believes citizens shd be required to buy coverage.TennesseeTicket
Headrick says "a right is something you don’t have to pay for, like free speech."TennesseeTicket
Taylor: requiring purchase (or subsidy or providing) is about risk mgt. 1 reason health ins is expensive is customers pay for uninsuredTennesseeTicket
Headrick, wearing white lab coat, says TennCare has paved the road for an exchange structure. Thinks Tennessee is ahead in that regard.James Harrison
Should contracts be allowed btwn physicians and Medicare recipients? Discussions have turned to Medicare reform itself.TennesseeTicket
Both Fleischmann and Wamp dance around the question if whether private contracting should be allowed between physicians and beneficiaries.James Harrison
Bhalla said he’d be against it, Headrick said she’d be for it, as did Taylor. Mayfield also says "that should be the way it works."James Harrison
Taylor gets applause for pointing out that in prescription drug benefit, prices were not negotiated with drug cos as with drs and hospitalsTennesseeTicket
Taylor: "privatizing Medicare is a bad idea" since insurance companies would put paperwork burden on drs to recoup higher reimb 4 themselvesTennesseeTicket
Taylor says it should be a "societal burden" that we all take care of our own health. "We’ve got to control our trips to McDonald’s."James Harrison
.@westonwamp decries Fleischmann and Mayfield ads for "demagoguery" instead of finding common ground on issues such as pre-exTennesseeTicket
Given chance to respond if their TV ads are "being too critical of the president," Mayfield and Fleischmann offer no comment.James Harrison
Strong statements against IPAB’s potential abuse of power, other perceived ills by all #TN03 candidates but Bhalla (who wasn’t sure of ?)TennesseeTicket
On support to end the Independent Payment Advisory Board, Bill Taylor says: "Finally, something Chuck Fleischmann and I agree about."James Harrison
On how to get more physicians into system, @RepChuck says tax credits to help with debt from medical school would help.TennesseeTicket
Mayfield and Taylor agree that residency expansion is necessary, but funding will be a challenge. Taylor says ins cos don’t contrib to edTennesseeTicket
On issue of physicians being paid more than mid-level providers, Wamp and Fleischmann say "no," Mayfield says "it depends on the situation."James Harrison
Debate wraps after one hour 47 minutes. Never strayed from health care, Wamp only candidate to call out others by name.James Harrison