Democrats unite behind Paul Smith at fundraiser

Even though some of the local Democratic Party faithful expressed their displeasure with Chairman Paul Smith by refusing to attend, the Choo Choo Imperial Ballroom was fairly filled with cheering supporters on Wednesday at the party’s annual Kefauver Dinner. Organizers said the event was sold-out.

Smith and his longtime friend, former Senate Majority Leader Ward Crutchfield, each received several ovations from the crowd at the urging of speakers ranging from Sen. Beverly Marrero of Memphis to Crutchfield’s daughter Missy, who heads the Chattanooga Department of Education, Arts & Culture, and who emceed the event.

The majority of those in attendance seemed willing to forgive and forget the elder Crutchfield’s 2005 arrest and 2007 conviction on federal bribery charges, though some were seen keeping their seats while the rest stood.

A few party stalwarts privately hinted that Smith may face a leadership challenge at the next re-organization meeting (to take place in Spring 2013), even as they asserted that the current rift is more personal than political. One member expressed a desire to see younger people move into party leadership, but said that the fundraiser is a time to emphasize party unity, adding that the re-organization will be the time to “air the dirty laundry.”

Missy Crutchfield used some of her time at the lectern to rather openly lobby mayoral candidate Sen. Andy Berke to continue the department she administers, which was created in 2005 by current Mayor Ron Littlefield, should he win the March 2013 election. (She also alluded to a common perception that Berke is a shoo-in by referring to the election as a “coronation.”)

D. Bruce Shine, a Kingsport attorney and former staffer for Estes Kefauver, gave a biographical sketch of the Tennessee Congressman, U.S. Senator, and vice presidential candidate. Other speakers included Rev. Kenneth Love, Rep. JoAnne Favors, Sen. Beverly Marrero, and U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen. Collectively they extolled the virtues of organized labor and excoriated Republican-led legislative changes such as the requirement for voters to show photo identification at the polling place.

Candidates in the November election were recognized on the podium: Favors, Frank Eaton, Dr. Mary Headrick, Jim Lewis, Andraé McGary, and Sandy Norris Smith all were declared “winners” by Love. Following their recognition, candidates in the 2013 municipal election were invited to stand.

The annual Kefauver award, chosen by the party chair, was presented to Sandy Lusk, Missy Crutchfield, Jane Bowen-Forsythe, and Roger Graham.

Full disclosure: I was not able to stay through the entire event, and therefore missed the keynote speech by U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen (D-Memphis). Times Free Press reporter Shelly Bradbury covered it through its conclusion.

The August election losers

Of course you can find the complete results of Thursday’s state primary and county general elections posted on many media outlets’ websites and at the Secretary of State’s site. My aim isn’t to replicate that information here, but to point to some of the outcomes that I count as painful reminders that not all goes well.

THE NUMBER ONE LOSER: People who didn’t vote. Some races are so close that we’re not sure who won. Others are so lopsided that it’s a viable assumption that a balanced cross-section of people wasn’t present. It may be a cliché, but it’s no less true that every vote counts. Uninformed voting is perhaps just as bad as abstinence, so the trick here is to avail oneself of knowledge and then vote. Even if one’s chosen candidates don’t prevail, it’s a win for the democratic process of effectively improving our government. If you don’t vote, you lose. Period.

LOSER: The Democratic Party. This loss goes back in part to prior legislative defeats that led to redistricting impacts. Reps. Tommie Brown, Mike Kernell, and Jeanne Richardson, along with Sen. Beverly Marrero, are among the casualties. Yesterday made it real. But even given these circumstances, multiple other failures are evident both locally (Chattanooga area) and statewide. The party comes across as fractured, incoherent, and unable to offer voters a convincing reason to look to them as champions of popular values. The U.S. Senate primary results left many party members asking, “Who?”

PARTIAL LOSER: The Tea Party. Yes, there were some victories (think Debra Moody in House District 81 CORRECTION 4:40 p.m. EDT I am advised that Rory Bricco had the Tea Party backing in Tipton County), but a closer look reveals that special interest spending likely had a lot more to do with some wins than grassroots galvanization did. And then there were losses: Sen. Doug Overbey handily defeated his rival Scott Hughes in District 2. Dawn White beat Richard Garvin in House District 37. And Zach Poskevich, who along with Brenda Lenard courted the Tea Party vote in the U.S. Senate primary, was obliterated by U.S. Sen. Bob Corker.

LOSER: Citizens of the City of Chattanooga who desire a truly transparent and accountable government. The internal audit setup we have now is far less than ideal, but the one we just voted to approve is worse in several ways. Yes, we needed to fix it, but not in this way.

SORE LOSER: Scottie Mayfield. After it became clear that U.S. Rep. Chuck Fleischmann had won nomination for re-election, Mayfield refused to concede the election, and asserted that the Hamilton County Election Commission surely had made a huge mistake, since the campaign’s polling showed different results than the actual ballots cast. Granted, there are a few troubling questions about the election commission’s tallies (more on that in another post, should time allow), but Mayfield’s handling of the situation struck some observers as petulant and amateur. (UPDATE 2:00 p.m. EDT: Mayfield has now conceded to Fleischmann.)

LOSER: Your humble blogger/webmaster. I could tell from visitor paths that people weren’t landing on the pages that contained information that best answered their search queries. Additionally, I was more surprised than I should have been by a few of the results, and that shows that I need to seek out and analyze information in better ways. I count process improvement as one of my strengths, though, and am committed to applying those principles to increasing my acumen and my delivery of information.

Others? Let me know.

House Democrats assess redistricting damage

The Republican-led committee in charge of new district maps for the state House of Representatives on Tuesday gave their Democratic counterparts a preview of the maps that will be discussed today.

The House Democratic Caucus held a meeting to go over the changes, and Tom Humphrey reports on the meeting:

In four of the new House districts, eight incumbent Democrats will be facing one another if they seek re-election.

They include Reps. [Tommie] Brown and JoAnne Favors of Chattanooga and Reps. Mike Stewart and Sherry Jones of Nashville. The other two districts are in Shelby County and pair Reps. Antonio Parkinson and [Jeanne] Richardson in one while Reps. Barbara Cooper and G.A. Hardaway are paired in another.

In one new district, incumbent Republican Jim Cobb of Spring City is paired with Democratic Rep. Bill Harmon of Dunlap.

Five new no-incumbent districts are created, all apparently intended to lean Republican. One is in northwest Knox County, including the Hardin Valley and Karnes area. The others are in Davidson County, Hamilton County, Rutherford County and Williamson County.

The Hamilton County Democratic Party meanwhile issued a statement that accuses Republicans of gerrymandering the state to create one-party rule, and going against the checks and balances intended by the nation’s Founding Fathers. (If only I could think of an example where another party has done something similar, I could demonstrate that this isn’t the first time this has happened. Even better would be an example where a party did so for multiple consecutive generations. Oh, well. It’s wrong no matter which party does it, and that’s the point here.)

The HCDP press release follows:

“The Republican agenda is clear. They intend to gerrymander our democracy into a one-party system in which no one who disagrees with the Republican elite has a voice,” said Hamilton County Democratic Chairman Paul Smith.

“This is not just a national or a state issue,” he continued. “Right here in Hamilton County and Chattanooga, we will be drastically affected by the tactics of Republicans in the Nashville statehouse. They’ve stated their goal—make it impossible for Democratic, or for that matter, independent views to be heard. They even attempt to stifle dissent within their own party. And in our own county, the Republican-dominated country commission seeks to maintain its iron grip on the nonpartisan school board in violation of the state constitution. We believe this is wrong and will be putting forth tremendous effort to ensure that those who hold opposing views can still participate in our democracy.”

The Founding Fathers went to great lengths to construct a system of checks and balances, incorporated into the Constitution, designed to prevent the tyranny of the majority over a minority, he noted. “The Democratic Party stands firm in support of the intent of the Constitution, and we will be sending that message to all of Hamilton County throughout 2012 and beyond.”

Strictly redistricting (say that five times really fast)

While several states have adopted new district maps, and more are in the approval process, Tennessee’s redistricting progress is slowed by partisanship and secrecy. Here are some thoughts about what we do know at this point. Continue reading

The powered of the county

The 2010 elections now are fading into memory, and the national campaigns for 2012 have already begun, so this seems as good a time as any to assess Chattanooga’s clout as measured by the roles our elected officials will be assuming. Party caucus elections have been held, committee assignments have been meted, and administrations are being assembled. How did we do? Continue reading